
Casa Marina Key West
Best for beach-first stays — Casa Marina is the oceanfront option with roughly 1,100 feet of private shoreline, two oceanfront pools (including an adults-only pool), watersports, and a full-service spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Casa Marina Key West is a historic 4-star oceanfront resort with private beach access and beachfront pools; read this if you want classic Key West oceanfront rooms, beach days, and a full-service spa. Havana Cabana at Key West is a 4-star Cuban-inspired, resort-style hotel in New Town with a prominent pool scene; read this if you want a theme-driven stay and a lively pool environment away from the main old-town strip.
Updated

Best for beach-first stays — Casa Marina is the oceanfront option with roughly 1,100 feet of private shoreline, two oceanfront pools (including an adults-only pool), watersports, and a full-service spa.

Best for a social pool vibe and themed design — Havana Cabana centers on a large outdoor pool and Cuban-flavored public spaces for travelers who want a resort-style scene without being on the main old‑town strip.
When Casa Marina Key West wins: choose Casa Marina if you want direct beach access, oceanfront pools, a full-service spa (Spa al Maré), and a historic, landmark setting a short walk toward Old Town and Duval Street.
When Havana Cabana at Key West wins: pick Havana Cabana if you prefer a Cuban-inspired, resort-style hotel with a single large pool and a strong on-property social scene in New Town, plus convenient self-parking and lower distance to the north-side beaches and services.
Bottom line: Casa Marina is the pick for beach access, oceanfront dining, and a resort/spa-focused Key West experience; Havana Cabana is a solid non-beach, design-forward alternative focused on pooltime and value in New Town.
| Category | Casa Marina Key West | Havana Cabana at Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic oceanfront resort, restored 1920s property with formal ballrooms and beachfront amenities | 4-star Cuban-inspired resort hotel with a lively pool scene and retro-themed public areas |
| Location | Oceanfront on Reynolds Street with private beach; closer to Higgs Beach and a walk toward Old Town | In Key West (New Town) on N. Roosevelt Blvd, set away from Duval Street's core |
| Size | 311 rooms across 4 floors | 106 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; family-friendly with an adults-only pool area | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools & water access | Two refurbished oceanfront pools (one adults-only, one family) plus private beach and watersports | One outdoor pool and one hot tub; poolside bar and pool sun loungers, but no private beach listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets including Dorada (oceanfront Baja-Med) and The Canary Room cocktail bar plus Flagler's and Morrison's Market | Floridita Food Truck / snack bar/deli and 1 bar/lounge; breakfast available (surcharge) |
| Spa & wellness | Spa al Maré (full-service spa with beachfront cabanas), large fitness center, yoga classes | Not published |
| Signature features | Largest private beach in Key West (~1,100 ft), historic landmark status, large event/wedding venues | Cuban-themed design and a prominent pool scene; multilingual staff and free self-parking |
| Parking & transport | Self-parking and valet available (fees); shuttle access to sister property The Reach | Free self parking and on-site scooter/moped and bicycle rentals; electric car charging station |
| Resort fee / extra charges | Mandatory daily resort charge with multiple inclusions (beach, pool, fitness, etc.) | Mandatory resort fee listed in supplier data (USD 61.88 per accommodation, per night) and a 1% service fee |
Casa Marina sits on Reynolds Street with private beach access and is within easy walking distance of some Old Town sights.
Choose Casa Marina for an oceanfront base that still gives straightforward walking access to Old Town sights.
Havana Cabana is in Key West’s New Town neighborhood on N. Roosevelt Blvd, set away from the island’s Old Town core.
Pick Havana Cabana if you want a quieter New Town base with easy parking and fewer crowds from Old Town.
Casa Marina has 311 rooms and suites across 22 named room types, including oceanfront suites and walkout lanai options.
Casa Marina suits travelers seeking oceanfront rooms or larger suites with resort-style amenities and historic character.
Havana Cabana offers 106 individually decorated guestrooms with a variety of premium and traditional room labels.
Havana Cabana fits travelers looking for compact, themed rooms with standard in-room conveniences and accessible options.
Casa Marina offers multiple on-site restaurants and bars, from oceanfront Dorada to the lobby cocktail bar The Canary Room.
Choose Casa Marina if you want oceanfront dining, a broader set of outlets, and on-site special-event dining options.
Havana Cabana’s food-and-drink offering is smaller, focused around a snack bar/deli and a food truck at times, plus a poolside bar.
Havana Cabana works for guests who want a casual, pool-focused food-and-drink experience rather than multiple formal restaurants.
Casa Marina’s signature amenity is its private beach plus two refurbished oceanfront pools (one adults-only, one family).
If beach and oceanfront pool time are priorities, Casa Marina delivers both in a single resort setting.
Havana Cabana’s main draw is its large outdoor pool and social pool atmosphere rather than beach access.
Pick Havana Cabana for a resort-style stay built around a single, active pool and poolside service.
Casa Marina includes Spa al Maré, one of the resort’s core wellness offerings, plus a large fitness facility and scheduled classes.
Casa Marina is better for travelers who want a full spa and class schedule alongside evening cocktail options.
Havana Cabana provides a social pool setting and basic wellness options but does not list a full-service spa in supplier data.
Havana Cabana suits guests who want casual active options and poolside evenings but not a dedicated spa program.

Casa Marina — private beachfront access with beachfront dining and watersports launched from the resort.

Havana Cabana — single, prominent pool with a poolside bar and a strong social scene.

Casa Marina — Spa al Maré, large fitness center, and scheduled yoga and fitness classes.

Havana Cabana — free self-parking on site and a New Town location that’s convenient if you plan to drive or explore north-side beaches.
Casa Marina is closer to Old Town attractions and within a walkable distance to some sites; Havana Cabana is in New Town and sits farther from Duval Street.
Casa Marina has roughly 1,100 feet of private beach. Havana Cabana’s listing does not show private beachfront access.
No—Havana Cabana is not adults-only; it’s listed as all-ages.
Casa Marina has Spa al Maré and on-site wellness programming. Havana Cabana’s supplier listing does not publish a full-service spa.
Explore how Casa Marina Key West stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·