Casa Marina Key West vs Nearby Hotels
Considering Casa Marina Key West but want to compare other hotels nearby? These guides show how Casa Marina Key West stacks up against popular alternatives.
Updated · 19 comparisons
All 19 Casa Marina Key West Comparisons

Casa Marina Key West vs Ocean Key Resort & Spa
Compare a beachfront classic at Casa Marina with the harborfront action of Ocean Key at Mallory Square. Choose private beach and event space or immediate sunset-pier access.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Pier House Resort & Spa
Compare Casa Marina Key West (historic oceanfront resort with private beach and multiple pools) vs Pier House Resort & Spa (Old Town waterfront hotel with spa and Mallory Square access).
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa
Casa Marina — oceanfront 4-star with private beach, two pools and Spa al Maré; family- and event-friendly.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs The Reach Key West, Curio Collection
Historic beachfront resort vs. smaller contemporary sister property — choose Casa Marina for scale and events, The Reach for a compact beachfront stay.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
Casa Marina Key West vs Parrot Key Hotel & Villas — oceanfront classic or tropical villa resort?
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Casa Marina: historic oceanfront resort with private beach and Spa al Maré. The Marker: modern seaport resort with three pools and poolside dining.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses
Historic oceanfront Casa Marina with private beach vs Southernmost-area resort with guesthouses and many room types.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection
Casual beachfront resort vs. Duval Street landmark — pick private beach and spa at Casa Marina or downtown energy at La Concha.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Ocean Key Resort A Noble House Resort
Compare beachfront Casa Marina with downtown Ocean Key — beach and resort amenities vs harborfront, walkable Old Town access.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Hilton Key West Resort & Marina
Historic oceanfront resort with private beach and beachfront spa; walkable to Old Town.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Historic oceanfront resort with private beach (Casa Marina) or modern marina hotel with dock access on Stock Island (The Perry).
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Havana Cabana at Key West
Historic oceanfront resort with private beach and oceanfront dining vs a Cuban‑themed New Town hotel with a lively pool scene.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs DoubleTree Resort
Casa Marina: historic oceanfront resort with private beach. DoubleTree: branded resort near the airport.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs The Gardens Hotel
Compare Casa Marina Key West (beachfront resort with spa) versus The Gardens Hotel (garden boutique near Duval).
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Southernmost House Adult Exclusive
Oceanfront resort (Casa Marina) vs historic adults-only mansion (Southernmost House) — choose resort amenities or immediate Southernmost Point access.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Winslow's Bungalows Key West Historic Inns
Compare Casa Marina's beachfront resort services and Spa al Maré with Winslow's bungalow-style Old Town stay at 725 Truman Avenue.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Eden House
Compare Casa Marina Key West’s oceanfront resort scale with Eden House’s intimate Old Town inn to pick the stay that matches your Key West plans.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs H2O Suites
Historic oceanfront resort with private beach vs adults-only suite hotel in Old Town — pick Casa Marina for family and beach amenities, H2O Suites for a compact adults-only stay.
Compare →
Casa Marina Key West vs Orchid Key Inn
Casa Marina: oceanfront resort with private beach and spa • Orchid Key Inn: adults-only boutique on Duval Street.
Compare →
Includes beach chairs & fitness center
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge